After decades of effort, the voluntary, collaborative approach to restoring the health and vitality of the Chesapeake Bay— the largest estuary in the United States—has not worked and, in fact, is failing. A diverse group of 57 senior scientists and policymakers have joined forces to save the Bay. This is our plan.

Senior Scientists And Policmakers For The Bay Join With Other Conservation Groups In Urging Better Regulation Of Tons Of Raw Animal Manure.

Thousands of tons of raw animal manure is put on Maryland farm fields each year from tens of millions of chickens and hundreds of thousands of pigs, cows, and other farm animals. Under pressure to reduce this significant source of Bay pollutants, the Maryland Department of Agriculture proposed soft new nutrient management regulations to deal with this problem last October but withdrew them under pressure from the farm and environmental community. These regulations were to better manage the farm application of manure, human sludge, and other fertilizers but were greatly weakened to meet the objections of the ag lobby.

After eight months of negotiations and efforts to strengthen the regulations as we have advocated in our Bay Action Plan [Nutrient Management Letter to Governor-Bay Cabinet], new regulations were proposed and published in the Maryland Register on June 29. These regs are still much too weak and fall well short of the Senior Scientists and Policymakers for the Bay science-based positions. Representatives of our group had discussed our positions in detail with the Bay Cabinet at a meeting last September. We have continued to advocate these common sense positions and members of our group sent detailed letter to the Governor and published an Op-ed in the Baltimore Sun ]NMR Sun OpEd No more half-measures June 18 2012 detailing the need for better management of animal manure and other nutrients.

Essentially, our recommendations center on the belief that that all animal manure—and all biosolids—should be regulated the same as human sludge from advanced wastewater treatment plants is regulated under MDE regs when these nutrient-containing materials are applied to farm land. Working with all major Maryland environmental groups, our recomemndations were fine tuned and those of other groups were combined in a JOINT STATEMENT calling for the adoption of the proposed regulations with 8 ESSENTIAL CHANGES. These changes address the shortcomings in the proposed manure regulations. The 8 Essential Changes in the proposed regs would do a lot to reduce nutrients that are choking the Bay–more than almost any other proposed or current law or regulation. NMR ENVIRO STATEMENT W Sign ons July 3 2012


The conservation community needs your help in working to gain the changes we have long supported. Remember the serious diseased fish and human infections in 1997 linked to excess nutrients from manure and other farm activities? Here’s help you can help in our uphill battle to improve the regulations:


The Joint Committee on Administrative, Executive, and Legislative Review held a legislative hearing on July 10 at which the Maryland Farm Bureau and rural legislators attacked the proposed regulations. Conservation groups testified in support of the adoption of the proposed regulations with the 8 Essential Changes. Please send a letter supporting the adoption of the proposed regulations with the 8 ESSENTIAL CHANGES. you should email it to the AELR Committee Chairs: Senator Paul Pinsky via Ian Ullman, <> and Delegate Anne Healey at:  Address the email to: Joint Committee on Administrative, Executive and Legislative Review, c/o Department of Legislative Services, Legislative Services Building, 90 State Circle, Annapolis, MD 21401 and send copies to the two Legislative Services staff members, Mr. Isaacson: and Ms. Razulis at: asking that your email ltr be delivered to all AELR Committee members.


Our group of Senior Scientists and Policymakers is working with others in the conservation community to assure a good turnout and to present a unified stand at the MDA hearings on the regs. You can present your support for adoption of the regulations as in the Joint Statement and of the 8 ESSENTIAL CHANGES and add your own personal insights and try to have others attend the meetings in Easton and Prince Frederick. The meetings run from 7:00 p.m. to 9:00 p.m.

Eastern Shore

Monday, July 23, 2012

Talbot Community Center

10028 Ocean Gateway

Easton, MD 21601

Southern Maryland

Wednesday, July 25, 2012

Calvert County Fairgrounds

140 Calvert Fair Drive

Prince Frederick, MD 20610


Written comments may be sent to Jo Mercer, Ed.D., Program Manager, MDA’s Nutrient Management Program, Maryland Department of Agriculture, 50 Harry S. Truman Parkway, Annapolis, MD 21401, or email:, or fax to (410) 841-5950. Comments will be accepted through August 13, 2012. Urge adoption of the proposed nutrient management regulations with the 8 ESSENTIAL CHANGES.



One Response to Senior Scientists And Policmakers For The Bay Join With Other Conservation Groups In Urging Better Regulation Of Tons Of Raw Animal Manure.

  1. I laud your fight for good regulations on raw animal manure and, of course, am in 100% agreement on all of the the 25 action items.

    However, what frustrates me no end is another letter writing campaign aimed at changing the minds of the people who have so rigidly opposed more stringent requirements. As has been proven repeatedly over the past 20+ years, the influence of the rich producers is simply too strong.

    What I propose is a coalition of the willing as a means of achieving better results outside of the politicians and the state agencies that are beholden to them.

    I believe a Bay Summit, something akin to the Climate Change Summit, wherein all the stakeholders are brought together for a major event to talk about the solutions with the goal of forming and agreement on who is going to be willing to do what to bring significant change in the outlook for the Bay.

    Yes, the agreement may not be binding, but, based on progress, neither have any of the state agreements that repeatedly set goals, then missed goals, then updated goals and still nothing has been accomplished.

    In the early days of my retirement I wrote letter after letter; letters to the editor of all the major newspapers, letters to state agency heads, to heads of committees, lettrs ad infinitum. Occassionally, I got the canned response. Most of the time, nothing. I finally gave up on that approach.

    I think it’s time to stop beating the dead horse and to take a totally different approach. Get everybody face to face, including the farmers the producers, the environmentalists, the lay ecologists and plain on interested citizens who want to show up. Present papers, have large plenary sessions, put people together in groups to hash out differences; compromise, develop common goals and get people to sign on. Create the kind of public exposure that makes it hard for people to opt out.

    Notice I didn’t include politicians. If they want to attend, let them come as interested citizens. They’ve burned up their right to be on the stage.